The End of an Era - Rethinking Menopause and Hormone Replacement Therapy

In light of the recent findings on Hormonesometimes low-dose DHEA and perhaps St. John's
Replacement Therapy (HRT) many women findwort work very well in controlling the symptoms
themselves with a big question about taking a littleof menopause.
pill.Dong quai, an adoptogenic, balances hormones.
A large, federally funded clinical trial, part of aVitex or Chaste Berry has been used for
group of studies called the Women's Healthdecades to regulate estrogen and progesterone
Initiative (WHI), has definitively shown for the firstproduction by working through the pituitary gland.
time that the hormones in question - estrogenBlack cohosh has been the menopausal "tonic" of
and progestin - are not the age-defying wonderNative Americans throughout history. Studies
drugs everyone thought they were. As if thathave shown, black cohosh extract, to provide as
weren't bad enough, the results proved thatmuch symptomatic relief as Premarin. DHEA can
taking these hormones together for more than ahelp with decreased libido and overall declining
few years actually increases a woman's risk ofenergy levels and St. John's wort can help combat
developing potentially deadly cardiovasculardepression and mood swings.
problems and invasive breast cancer, amongBuilding Bone/Preventing Osteoporosis
other things. The principal message was takingIn dealing with supplementation for women at any
estrogen and progestin for years in the hope ofage, preserving and building bone density should
preventing a heart attack or stroke can no longeralways be considered. Unfortunately, only about
be considered a valid medical strategy.11% of women get adequate calcium everyday.
Here at last was a rare moment of clarity. TheStudies have clearly shown the importance of
debate over the long-term benefits and risks ofCalcium in building and preserving bone. Magnesium
HRT has lasted for decades. Now we have atdeficiency is as much a problem in bone health as
least a few concrete answers. This wasn't justinadequate calcium. Again, more than 80% of
another isolated study contradicting the last oneAmerican women are magnesium deficient, and
to make headlines. Federal health officialsbecause calcium and magnesium work in balance
announced that the jury was finally in-and that thewith each other, it is important to supplement
drug Prempro (a combination of estrogen andthese together. Supplemental Vitamin D is
progestin) does significantly more harm than goodnecessary for the proper absorption of calcium,
when taken for long periods of time. Womenand Boron has also been shown to have
have been told for decades that estrogen takenbone-building properties.
with progestin would not only ease hot flashesNumerous studies have also shown ipriflavone to
and insomnia but help preserve bone strength,be particularly useful in the treatment of low bone
mental acuity and, most important, heart health.density and osteoperosis. Ipriflavone, a derivative
There's no question that HRT can ease the acuteof the soy isoflavone diadzein not only prevents a
symptoms of menopause, and the claim abouttype of bone cell called osteoclasts from breaking
bone strength has held up to scrutiny. But afterdown bone, but also stimulates other bone cells,
observing more than 16,000 women for roughlyosteoblasts, to build new bone. Ostevone, the
five years, researchers found conclusively thatbranded Ipriflavone I recommend, has been
the hormones in Prempro raise the risk of heartchemically shown to rival their not so healthful
attack, stroke, blood clots and breast cancer. Thepharmaceutical counterparts, and without the
federally sponsored study was supposed to rundevastating side effects.
for eight years, but the five-year results were soFoods and Phytonutrients
decisive that researchers cut it short and urgedPerhaps not as easy as swallowing a pill, eating a
the participants to stop taking their pills.healthier diet can significantly ease the transition
The findings are so striking that the study wasthrough menopause, as well as provide additional
stopped three years short of its scheduledbenefits in treating or preventing other illnesses.
completion. With more than an estimated 13.5Current research points to the role of
million U.S. Women using hormone replacementphytoestrogens (phyto means plant), natural plant
therapy (HRT) to treat symptoms of menopausehormones that provide a mild estrogenic activity
such as hot flashes and vaginal dryness, and toin the body. By incorporating foods high in these
protect against bone-thinning osteoporosis, it's nointo your diet, not only do you ease symptoms
wonder the news caused such gasps and the talkof menopause, they also provide the added
hasn't stopped since. Women across the U.S.benefits of reducing your risk of heart disease -
immediately called their doctors, mothers,still the leading cause of death for older women.
daughters, and friends, questioning whether theySoy
should still be taking their pills and what, if any, areWhen it comes to easing menopause symptoms,
their alternatives?soy seems nothing less than a wonder food. A
Why HRT in the first place?number of recent studies have found soy foods
For decades, millions of women have been toldto reduce these symptoms due to the powerful
that HRT is a veritable fountain of youth. Morephytoestrogens called isoflavones that they
than 40% of all women in the U.S. start somecontain. Soy is what is known as an "adaptogenic"
form of HRT in their menopause years. Although- the phytoestrogens genistein and diadzein in soy
it is estimated 50% of the women on HRTcan have an estrogen like effect if your estrogen
discontinue it within the first year, many continuelevels are low, and will actually bind to estrogen
it well into their 70s and 80s, convinced that thereceptor sites and block estrogen if levels are too
little pills will stave off aging and a host of otherhigh. For this reason, soy is a great natural way
health concerns.to balance hormone levels and can be used as a
Once upon a time the concept of menopause andsafe alternative to hormone replacement therapy,
its symptoms were almost unheard of becauseoffering most of the benefits, without the risks or
the vast majority of women rarely lived longside effects. Other studies have also suggested
enough to experience them. And, for the womenthat these same isoflavones can increase bone
who did survive, menopause was seen as amass and reduce cholesterol levels - two other
marker for imminent and inevitable physicalmain concerns for menopausal women. Functional
decline. Until the early 1900's that is, when it wassoy beverages like OptiPRO S have been
first discovered that extracts from pigs' ovariesspecifically formulated with high standardized levels
could "put off old age for a score of years," or atof isoflavones, calcium, magnesium, boron,
least "mitigate its effects when it has assertedselenium and specialized enzymes to provide one
itself with all its terrors." By the early 1940s, drugof the simplest, easiest ways to mitigate
makers were mass-producing estrogen fromsymptoms, while protecting cardiovascular health,
pregnant mares' urine (hence the brand namebone density, lower cancer risk, and manage
Premarin). And by 1960 the New England Journalweight.
of Medicine was commending the drug forFruits, Vegetables and Whole Grains - It's
"everyone with evidence of an estrogen lack"-important to make sure your diet includes plenty
which is to say virtually every woman over 50.of phytonutrient rich foods such as fruits,
Over the years the medical arguments forvegetables and whole grains. Phytoestrogens can
prescribing estrogen may have changed, but thebe found in apples, carrots, plums, peas, green
idea that a single pill might turn back the clock stillbeans, barley, oats and rye.
holds promise to many. Last year U.S.Cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli contain
pharmacists filled some 45 million prescriptions forthe powerful phyochemical indole-3-carbinol, shown
Premarin and an additional 22 million for Prempro,to convert powerful estrogens in the body to
which consists of the same drug with addedweaker, less carcinogenic ones. Citrus fruits and
progestin.other foods high in biflavonoids, such as
Menopause is not a disease - why do we treat itblueberries, cherries and grapes are also
as one?particularly beneficial.
Perhaps the real question we need to answer is -Biflavonoids not only strengthen the circulatory
is it time to stop treating menopause as asystem, which is helpful in treating hot flashes,
disease, and to look at it as a natural, normal,menstrual flow and varicose veins, but they are
physiological process. The idea that our bodies failalso powerful anti-oxidants useful in the prevention
us at menopause is ludicrous, sexist and just plainof cancer.
wrong. And yes, for many there are undeniableFlax seed is one of the richest sources of
unpleasant symptoms that go along with it. ButOmega-3 essential fatty acids as well as one of
wouldn't it be more appropriate to treat thosethe best sources of a form of phytoestrogen
symptoms, perhaps even naturally, rather thancalled lignans.
treat menopause as a medical condition requiringLignans have been shown to reduce hot flashes
pharmaceuticals?and are beneficial in the prevention and treatment
What are the alternatives?of breast and colon cancer, lowering cholesterol
For millions of women, the question of whether tolevels and promoting breast and vaginal health.
take hormone replacement therapy after
menopause just got more confusing. And theExercise
thought of quitting HRT if it has successfullyThere's no better natural way to treat both the
mitigated symptoms can be a scary thought. Ifphysical, as well as the emotional, symptoms of
you're using HRT in hopes it will protect yourmenopause than with exercise. Exercise relieves
heart, prevent osteoporosis or relieve symptomsstress, which is known to exacerbate symptoms,
such as hot flashes, night sweats, insomnia,not to mention improves mood, builds strength,
memory loss, vaginal dryness and declining libido,helps control weight, and increases bone density.
you will be happy to know that many womenIn light of the recent findings, some physicians will
have found tremendous success in a more holisticchange their thinking dramatically; others will not
approach of herbs and nutritional supplements,change at all and will be as proactive for HRT as
whole foods - particularly soy, and exercise.they've ever been. One thing is for sure,
Herbs -Vitaminshowever, it's time for women to take
Long before Premarin, women sought reliefresponsibility for their own bodies and how to
through herbal remedies. A basic regimen ofbest protect themselves from osteoporosis and
vitamins, minerals and a few herbs work veryother ravages of age without resorting to
well to relieve the symptoms of menopause.old-fashioned hormones. The world of menopause
Every woman has different needs, but basically amanagement is in for some big changes, and the
program that includes calcium, magnesium, blackage of estrogen, without question, is over.
cohosh, vitex (chaste berry) dong qui and